Why You Shouldn’t Ignore that One-Star Review (and How to Make it Work For You)

You receive an email that someone left a comment on your profile, so you start scrolling through your Google reviews or Instagram comments with a fresh cup of coffee, feeling like a boss. But wait, no, someone dropped a one-star review, complete with enough sass to fuel your next meltdown. Oof.

Hold on, before you delete, or reply with something you’ll definitely regret, let’s talk about why negative comments aren’t actually the end of the world. In fact, handled the right way, they can be marketing gold.

Why you need to respond - even if you’d rather run and hide

People are watching (yes, even the lurkers - especially the lurkers)

Most potential customers stalk reviews and comments before deciding if you’re worth their hard-earned cash. An estimated 90% of consumers today will read reviews online before making a purchase decision. When those potential customers see you respond to criticism with grace (or at least good grammar), they think:

• Wow, these folks actually care.
• They’re human! (Not some faceless corporation.)
• If something goes wrong, they’ll fix it.

It’s your chance to show off your brand’s personality

A cheeky, kind, or empathetic reply doesn’t just calm the angry commenter; it broadcasts your tone to everyone else reading. A boring, robotic response? Forgettable. A thoughtful or even lightly humorous one? That’s memorable. Those 90% of review-reading consumers want to see that they’ll have a good experience working with you, give them a great first impression by sharing your personality.

You might actually win the person back

Some complainers just want to be heard. Nail the response right, and you could transform them from keyboard warriors into loyal fans. Seriously! Sometimes the most diehard brand advocates started as their harshest critics.

How to spin bad feedback into something great

On Social Media: Keep it snappy, friendly, and public - at least at first. If someone comments, “This is the WORST burger I’ve ever had,” try not to get defensive. 

Try: “Oh no! That’s definitely not what we aim for. Slide into our DMs so we can make this right (and maybe change your mind on that burger 😉).”

This does three things:

1. Shows everyone else you’re responsive. Quick responses show you’re on top of your game.
2. Keeps the public conversation short, avoid letting the drama snowball.
3. Opens a private space to fix the issue.

With Google reviews: Reply as if everyone in the world is reading—because they are! Thank them for their feedback, apologize sincerely, and explain how you’ll improve. 

Example: “Hi Sam, we’re so sorry your order wasn’t up to our usual standard. We’ve talked to our team and would love the chance to do better. If you’d be open to it, please email us at hello@awesomebiz.com and we’ll sort you out.”

This tells the next potential customer you care enough to make things right.

When they send you Direct Responses (DMs, emails): Here’s where you can really personalize. Use their name, reference exactly what went wrong, and if possible, offer a solution like a discount, replacement, or just a heartfelt apology. Don’t copy-paste, people can sniff out a template from a mile away. Your customer spent the time to write you a message, show them the courtesy of making the same effort.

Online reviews can be a great tool for your brand, if you know how to handle them. 

Remember these 4 tips when responding to customers online:

1. Use their name whenever possible, it feels more personal
2. Apologize first. Then explain, or offer to fix it.
3. Take it offline, either through phone, email, or DM. Try to avoid back-and-forth debates in public.
4. Follow up after resolving the issue. Often time, people will update their review if you turn things around. 

‍